Lära historia genom källor: Undervisning och lärande av historisk källtolkning i grundskolan och gymnasieskolan

Vad är kritiska aspekter när mellanstadie- och gymnasieelever lär sig resonera historiskt i arbete med historisk källtolkning? Det är en av frågorna som Patrik Johansson undersöker i sin avhandling.

Fakta
Disputation

2019-10-11

Titel (sv)

Lära historia genom källor: Undervisning och lärande av historisk källtolkning i grundskolan och gymnasieskolan

Titel (eng)

Learning history through historical source materials : Teaching and learning historical source interpretation in primary and secondary school

Författare

Patrik Johansson

Handledare

Professor Kenneth Nordgren, Karlstads universitet Doktor Kristina Lanå, Stockholms universitet

Opponent

Doktor Ingmarie Danielsson Malmros, Malmö universitet

Institution

Institutionen för de humanistiska och samhällsvetenskapliga ämnenas didaktik.

Lärosäte

Stockholms universitet

Länkar
Läs hela avhandlingen (pdf)
Läs Skolportens intervju med Patrik Johansson

Abstract in English:

This doctoral thesis is concerned with how students learn historical source interpretation and the design of facilitating teaching practices. Source interpretation is at the core of historians’ professional practice and, while being a key aspect of historical learning, it is sometimes misunderstood or misrepresented in history teaching. To better understand these issues two educational design research field studies were conducted in middle and upper secondary schools to explore how students learn historical source interpretation. The historical content in upper secondary school concerned the process of democratisation in Sweden, while the middle school content was the Viking Age. Source materials in upper secondary school included various text sources, while archaeological artefacts were used in middle school.

The research object was historical source interpretation, or the ability to understand the meaning of sources in relation to the historical questions and contexts formulated and dealt with in history teaching. Source interpretation is one element of the ability to reason historically. It is a theoretical construct that has a heuristic function along with the development of historical consciousness. Four research questions are addressed: i) What do middle and upper secondary school students know when they have developed the ability to reason historically when engaged in source interpretation, ii) What are critical aspects of learning to reason historically when engaged in source interpretation, iii) What are similarities and differences between middle and upper secondary school students’ learning of historical reasoning in source interpretation, and iv) How can history teaching facilitate the learning of historical reasoning through source interpretation?

An interventionist and theory-informed research methodology, in the form of learning study, was used to develop teaching practices while generating empirical data. A compilation of four peer-reviewed articles simultaneously contribute knowledge to the practice of history teaching and to the theory of history didactics. Two articles address the first two questions of the qualitative meaning of learning source interpretation using phenomenography and variation theory to analyse students’ perceptions and to identify the critical aspects of discernment that students must learn. From the perspective of variation theory, it is argued that learning source interpretation can be regarded as obtaining differentiated ways of seeing, as previous experiences are supplemented with more complex perceptions.

The third question is addressed by comparing students’ developing of source interpretation skills in middle and upper secondary school. One finding of the comparison is that younger students’ learning reflects an increasing understanding of what history is, whereas older students learn to use the disciplinary tools and methods of history. Two articles address the final question regarding the role of teaching by combining content-based conversation analysis with variation theory to analyse students’ learning processes when working with source interpretation tasks. It is argued that students’ preunderstandings can be regarded and used as resources in teaching and learning. Finally, seven design principles are suggested to guide teachers in organising their teaching practice. These include motivating historical research through source work and activating historical consciousness through sources.

Sidan publicerades 2019-09-27 09:50 av Moa Duvarci Engman
Sidan uppdaterades 2019-12-11 16:47 av Moa Duvarci Engman


Konferenser
Fortbildning
Skolbibliotek
  Konferensen äger rum 1-2 december 2020 i Stockholm.

Skolbibliotek

Vi bjuder in till två dagars fortbildning för skolbibliotekarier, skolledare och alla som samarbetar med biblioteket. Ta del av forskares, bibliotekariers, rektors, lärares, journalisters och författares perspektiv för att skapa ett kraftfullt och modernt skolbibliotek. Välkommen!

Läs mer och boka plats
SKOLPORTENS MAGASIN
Skolportens magasin
  Skolporten nr 3/2020 – ute 15 maj

Skolportens magasin

Intervju: Möt forskaren Gunnlaugur Magnússon, som saknar de mest fundamentala frågorna i debatten. Tema: Rollen som skolchef – så komplex och utsatt är den.

Läs mer här
Kommande disputationer