Språkliga redskap – språklig beredskap – En praktiknära studie om elevers ämnesspråkliga deltagande i ljuset av inkluderande undervisning

Maria Rubin vill med sin forskning visa på möjligheter och hinder avseende gymnasieelevers ämnesspråkliga deltagande i undervisningen.



Titel (sv)

Språkliga redskap – språklig beredskap – En praktiknära studie om elevers ämnesspråkliga deltagande i ljuset av inkluderande undervisning


Maria Rubin


Professor Jonas Aspelin, Malmö universitet Professor Maaike Hajer, Malmö universitet


Professor Åsa Wedin, Högskolan Dalarna


Malmö universitet

Läs hela avhandlingen (pdf)
Läs pressmeddelande
Läs Skolportens intervju med Maria Rubin

Abstract in English:

The aim of the study is to shed light on opportunities and constraints regarding the pupils´ participation in subject-specific discourse in the classroom. The thesis has its point of departure in two areas of research, namely research on inclusion and research on content teaching in multilingual classes and, in particular, content based approaches for second language learners. These converge in common issues concerning where and how pupils are provided with the prerequisites for participation in regular instruction. The objective of the study is also to discuss the prerequisites of an inclusive instruction in terms of inclusive didactic building blocks. The teaching context is that of the shared programme subject, Medicine, in the vocational upper secondary school Health and Social Care Programme. By way of various actions the instruction evolves in the direction of language oriented content teaching and language oriented learning activities are conducted. Research endorses educational methods, and the pivotal role of teachers in these methods, that support pupils´ linguistic and cognitive development through an explicit focus on academic language proficiency. The theoretical framework is rooted in socio-cultural perspectives on language, second language development and learning. The study is designed as a practice-based action research study where the researcher collaborates with three teachers who are motivated to develop their language oriented content teaching. The action research project aims to support the participants in their joint formulation and reflection on development needs in their own practices and is directed both towards the professional development of the teachers and the development of their practices.

The results from the exploratory phase answer the question about what it is that characterises the teachers´ typical learning activities in the classroom, as well as the opportunities and constraints that exist for the students’ participation in subject-specific discourse. Typical learning activities are characterised by the striving of the teachers’ to support the pupils’ understanding of the subject-specific language. Opportunity arises for the pupils to participate in subject-specific discourse given that the teacher and pupils ascribe the same signification to the words. The pupils’ associations and the lack of contextualisation in the content classroom threaten to constrain the pupils´ participation. The pupils’ participation is constrained when the pupils lack strategies and understanding of the content of the text. The results from the second phase answer the question about the opportunities and challenges that emerge for the pupils’ participation in subject-specific discourse when the learning activities in the classroom become language oriented. The actions are planned and carried out on the basis of the development needs defined by the teacher in her practice. Four language oriented learning activities are organised for whole classes and smaller groups alike. During the first two language oriented learning activities new opportunities emerge for the pupils to participate in subject-specific discourse when the teacher asks them to first repeat a statement so as to then write a joint formulation thus providing an opportunity for a joint construction zone. During the third and the fourth actions, opportunities are created for the pupils to participate in subject-specific discourse with the whole class after the pupils have named separate words, and the teacher opens up for continued discussion. Through the language oriented content teaching, the focus is directed to the functional side of language. The results show that it is very demanding for individual teachers to test and change their teaching practices, and reveal constraints regarding framework factors and organisational issues. Moreover, the results reveal the importance of opportunities for teachers to reflect upon, and to question their practice, and to assume an investigatory approach so as to increase their knowledge and further integrate language oriented content teaching. Finally, in the thesis, a re-analysis is conducted in the light of Marianis’ model of High challenge High support. The results point to an expectation that the pupil already possesses sufficient familiarity with different tools to be able to participate unaided. Furthermore, the pupils’ participation in subject-specific discourse is constrained when pupils and teachers assign different meanings to words. In spite of the teacher’s planning and macro-scaffolding, the teacher also needs to improvise in the moment and support pupils by micro-scaffolding. The re-analysis shows how complicated it is for the teacher, in spite of the language orientation, to both support and challenge different pupils and to bring about a movement between different levels of challenge and support. During the action research process the teacher becomes steadily more aware of pupils in need of various forms of support and challenge, at the same time as the dilemma arises as to whom the teacher should prioritize and plan for. The complexity can be understood on the basis of what Biesta calls Internal Exclusion, that is, that students can participate without having access to the subject content. In this complexity, second language didactics, inclusion and special needs education all converge in a constant process of meeting pupils´ needs, needs that arise through diversity in the classroom.

A prerequisite for an inclusive teaching of school subjects is that the teacher understands the individual differences within the subject-specific teaching. Finally, the discussion reflects on how inclusive building blocks can support teachers’ striving towards an inclusive working practice in which they promote secure forms of collaboration, support a developing autonomy, respond to, and make visible, the pupil’s (pre)understanding in the moment, support the creation of the pupils’ social relationships plan for an ongoing movement between support and challenge, plan for the diversity of the students and for students with difficulties, plan for pupils’ active participation in subject-specific discourse, and promote peer support to meet diversity. A general result from the study illustrates that qualitative aspects of pupils’ participation are pivotal for inclusive education.

Sidan publicerades 2019-06-14 09:51 av Susanne Sawander

  Konferensen äger rum 5-6 maj 2020 i Stockholm.


Vi bjuder in till två dagars fortbildning för skolbibliotekarier, skolledare och alla som samarbetar med biblioteket. Ta del av forskares, bibliotekariers, rektors, lärares, journalisters och författares perspektiv för att skapa ett kraftfullt och modernt skolbibliotek. Välkommen!

Läs mer och boka plats
Kommande disputationer
5 mest lästa på FoU

”Lek är en bra social träning”

Ett forskningsprojekt på Grebyskolans fritidshem gav både samsyn och utvecklad lek. Läs artikeln ur senaste numret av Skolportens magasin här.

Så kan skolnärvaro främjas

Att skolfrånvaro och psykisk ohälsa hos unga hänger ihop har uppmärksammats under de senaste åren. En ny forskningsöversikt har sammanställt kunskapsläget för vilka faktorer som främjar skolnärvaro.

Consequences of school grading systems on adolescent health: evidence from a Swedish school reform

A new study has examined a reform of the Swedish school system; a reform centred on the introduction of grades and increased use of testing, especially standardised national tests, in the 6th and 7th school year. The reform had an indirect effect on psychosomatic symptoms and life satisfaction for these pupils. The negative effects of the reform were generally stronger for girls.

Elever med erfarenhet av robotar kritiska till att ha dem i klassrummet

Digitaliseringen och samhällets snabba tekniska utveckling har bidragit till diskussioner och tester av pedagogiska robotar i skolan. Ny forskning från Göteborgs universitet visar att elever med erfarenhet av robotar som läser av och analyserar känslor är mer negativa till dem än elever som inte träffat på dessa robotar tidigare.

In the Principal’s Office: Clark Elementary’s Isley shares strategies to develop teachers

Virginia elementary-school principal Anna Isley says building leadership skills of teachers can help boost retention rates and improve student performance. Isley, who began her career as a teacher, says connecting with other teachers in her first year set her on the path to success.