The Ecology of Mary’s Mathematics Teaching: Tracing Co-determination within School Mathematics Practices

Anna Pansell vill med sin avhandling fördjupa förståelsen för vilka möjligheter och begränsningar som skapas i en matematiklärares undervisningsekologi. I sin studie har hon utforskat hur andra lärare, läroböcker och läroplaner påverkar matematiklärare och deras undervisning.

Fakta
Disputation

2018-11-23

Titel (eng)

The Ecology of Mary’s Mathematics Teaching: Tracing Co-determination within School Mathematics Practices

Författare

Anna Pansell

Handledare

Docent Lisa Björklund-Boistrup, Stockholms universitet Professor Paul Andrews, Stockholms universitet

Opponent

Professor Uwe Gellert, Freie Universität, Berlin

Institution

Institutionen för matematikämnets och naturvetenskapsämnenas didaktik.

Lärosäte

Stockholms universitet

Länkar
Läs hela avhandlingen (pdf)
Läs Skolportens intervju med Anna Pansell

Abstract in English:

Teachers’ mathematics teaching has been studied in many different ways. Such studies not often include more contexts than the teacher’s teaching practice. An assumption in this thesis is that in order to create a deeper understanding of mathematics teachers’ teaching we also need to study the contexts around mathematics teachers, and in relation to each other. Together such contexts create an environment for teachers’ teaching. The determination of how mathematics is taught is not decided in any of the contexts alone. Rather, all contexts participate in the determination of how mathematics is taught and teachers need to negotiate how different contexts privilege both mathematics and mathematics education. In this study, I have studied one teacher’s, Mary’s, teaching practice as well as three contexts from her close environment, the teacher group she participated in, the textbooks she used, and the national curriculum she was bound to follow. To study how mathematics and mathematics teaching was privileged in the four studied contexts became a way to trace how the contexts participate in the determination, in short, their co-determination of how mathematics is taught.

With an aim to deepen the understanding of how the environment of a teacher’s teaching enables and constrains mathematics teaching, the four contexts were studied in relation to each other in different ways, in four studies. First, the context of Mary’s mathematics teaching was studied in relation to the teacher group in how the justifications of Mary’s mathematics teaching was constituted in relation to a teacher group discussion. Second, Mary’s teaching of problem-solving was studied in relation to how problem-solving was privileged in both mathematics textbook and national curriculum. Third, praxeology was explored as an analytical tool to understand how mathematics was privileged in teaching practice in relation to the privileging of mathematics in textbooks. Fourth, all four contexts were studied to trace arguments and principles for teaching rational numbers and how these enable and constrain the teaching of rational numbers.

To address these different contexts, ATD as described by Chevallard was adopted. In ATD, the environment of contexts with influence of teachers’ practices, is described as an ecology with levels that co-determine each other. The studied contexts represented some of these levels of co-determination. The privileging of mathematics and mathematics teaching was studied from a varied data material. Data from Mary’s teaching practice was transcripts of classroom observations and interviews. Data from the teacher group was transcripts of teacher meetings. Data from the textbook context was the textbooks and teacher guides Mary used. Data from the context of the national curriculum was the mathematics syllabus accompanied with clarifying and explanatory comments.

The analyses revealed a strong resemblance of the mathematical communication between the different contexts. They all emphasised similar approaches to problem-solving, aspects of rational numbers, mathematical values, or explanations of angles. Mary, however, anchored her arguments for mathematics teaching in partially different theoretical principles than those privileged in the ecology. Theoretical principles were not explicitly communicated in any context. They were inferred from the communication. An implication generated by these findings is the importance for teachers to engage in the principles behind the privileging expressed in contexts they need to negotiate. These principles need to be discussed and challenged. Another implication is the relevance of allowing for teachers to engage in research literature, and to have influences from other sources than their immediate contexts. The thesis also point to the need to study textbooks and national curriculum, not in terms of how they are enacted by teachers, but what they privilege. By doing so teachers practices may be understood in the sense of what teachers have to negotiate, where the consequence is a deeper understanding of constraints and affordances for teachers’ teaching practices.

Sidan publicerades 2018-10-30 11:21 av Susanne Sawander
Sidan uppdaterades 2019-01-22 07:47 av Susanne Sawander


Konferenser
Fortbildning
Rektor i förskolan

Rektor i förskolan

Den här konferensen fokuserar på din roll som chef och ledare med högaktuella föreläsningar om det pedagogiska ledarskapet och din professionsutveckling. Hur leder du i förändring och hur görs en nulägesanalys? Vi tar avstamp i de frågor som är specifika för förskolans verksamhet, men belyser även ämnen utifrån din yrkesroll som chef över en mångbottnad verksamhet.

Läs mer och boka plats
SKOLPORTENS MAGASIN
Finalist till Publishingpriset 2019!

Finalist till Publishingpriset 2019!

Skolportens forskningsmagasin är nominerat till Publishingpriset 2019 för andra året i rad!

Läs mer här!
Kommande disputationer
Lediga tjänster
Fler platsannonser
5 mest lästa på FoU

Här är 9 punkter för ett gott ledarskap

Chef-redaktionen har kokat ner 20 år av vetgirighet, skriverier och kunskaper i 9 steg till gott ledarskap.

How to set up interest-based reading groups

A three-step plan for using surveys to gauge students’ interests as a basis for forming small reading discussion groups.

Tool gauges use of Google in K-12 classrooms

Google has unveiled ”transformation reports” to give educators data on how often various Google offerings are actually used and for which specific tasks. This is important because a study last year by BrightBytes found the majority of software licenses purchased by schools went unused and another study by LearnTrials revealed just 9% of education-technology tools are used to their intended extent.

”Risken är att barn med PANS får fel diagnos”

Från nöjd och harmonisk till aggressiv och ångestfylld. Personlighetsförändringen kommer snabbt och oförklarligt hos barn som drabbas av PANS. Ett neuropsykiatriskt tillstånd som kan påminna om autism och adhd, men där forskarna anar ett samband mellan en vanlig infektion och kroppens immunsystem.

Tidig insats i väntan på autismutredning prisas

Ett förskolebarn som ska utredas för autism behöver insatser direkt i väntan på utredning. Därför har det neuropsykiatriska småbarnsteamet på habiliteringscentrum i Region Jönköpings län skapat ett stödmaterial för föräldrar och förskolepedagoger. En satsning som nu belönas med priset Life Watch Award 2019.